Al Castello Ristorante Italiano

What to order.

1. 🥇

   Lasagna di Manzo

   $20.95 · See all lasagnas in San Jose

   One diner calls it the best in the county. Others report a plate that tasted microwaved with the sauce separating, and a vegetariana that ran greasy when cut.

   6.2 Early ranking
2. 🥈

   Spaghetti alla Carbonara

   $19.95 · See all carbonaras in San Jose

   A light cream sauce with pancetta rather than the Roman egg emulsion. Diners who want a gentler sauce rate it highly; purists reject the cream, and takeout can arrive dry.

   5.5 Medium confidence