Defonte's Sandwich Shop

What to order.

1. 🥇

   Classic Italian Sub (half)

   $18.00 · See all italian sandwiches in New York City

   A Red Hook institution praised for its Italian combo on fresh crunchy bread. Two diners found the Nicky Special cold cut sub vinegary or bland.

   7.4 Limited data
2. 🥈

   Chicken Parmesan Hero

   $9.95 · See all chicken parms in New York City

   A Red Hook hero several diners call the best chicken parm of their lives and best in class. One found it mediocre.

   7.4 Limited data