American / Cocktail Bar · $$$
Paper Plane
72 S. First St., San Jose, CA · Downtown San Jose
What to order.
-
Chicken Parm Sandwich
Press credential is real but current named-dish Yelp volume is thin. Mercury News Feb 12 2019 bracket (finalist, not winner): 'Paper Plane, the downtown San Jose cocktail bar, beat out The Counter in Walnut Creek and San Jose, while the South Bay's Starbird bested San Ramon's Plucked Chicken & Beer.' Mercury News Feb 19 2019 final: 'Pinky & Red's just barely beat out San Jose's Paper Plane with 54 percent of the votes' (runner-up). The 2019 bracket was specifically about the fried-chicken-sandwich dish lineage. Current live menu (paperplanesj.com/food) names a Chicken Parm Sandwich: fried chicken cutlet, marinara, pesto mayo, ciabatta, potato chips. Caveats (Confidence: medium): the Chicken Parm is NOT in Paper Plane's Yelp Popular Dishes top-5 (Chicken and Waffle Sliders, Brussel Sprout Tacos, Chicken Wings, Prime Rib rank higher) — so live dish-specific review volume is thin. TripAdvisor dish quote on this restaurant names wings, not the Chicken Parm: 'The wings and guacamole were awesome.' No press/review-sourced photo of THIS specific sandwich from a credible source within scope was surfaced (GAP — no image_url attached). Pricing not surfaced from any aggregator or menu source (GAP — price left null). The link from the 2019 Mercury News fried-chicken-sandwich bracket to the current Chicken Parm Sandwich is an inference, not a verified continuation. Sources: https://mercurynews.com/2019/02/12/vote-now-best-bay-area-fried-chicken-sandwich-heres-the-amazing-eight ; https://mercurynews.com/2019/02/19/vote-best-bay-area-fried-chicken-sandwich-heres-the-top-two ; https://www.paperplanesj.com/food ; https://m.yelp.com/biz/paper-plane-san-jose-2 ; https://www.tripadvisor.com/Restaurant_Review-g33020-d8401710-Reviews-Paper_Plane-San_Jose_California.html
7.0 Medium confidence