Classic Cheese Pie

Why people love it

Brand-new: a crisp, foldable Staten Island-style cheese pie with bright sauce and oregano. Every review so far comes from its opening weeks; no critique has surfaced yet.

What people mention most

• real ny style9
• crispy crust5
• good sauce5
• quality cheese2
• thin crust2
• chewy crust2
• good cheese ratio2
• foldable1

On the menu

A classic New York-style cheese pie from a 17th Street shop that opened in September 2026, run by an owner raised on Staten Island pizza; $23 Monday to Thursday. Price is the regular pie price from the shop's own ordering page, which does not state the size.