XL 20" Cheese

Why people love it

A huge, crisp New York slice cut from a 20-inch pie. Recent critics call it oily, soggy or sweet-sauced, and some delivery pies have arrived cold.

What people mention most

• big slice20
• real ny style18
• crispy crust14
• thin crust10
• good value8
• good sauce7
• foldable7
• overpriced5

Criticism

• greasy3
• soggy3
• reheated2
• bland2
• doughy2

On the menu

Tony Gemignani's 20-inch New York-style cheese pie, tomato sauce and mozzarella, at the Haight Street Slice House; a 12-inch is $22. Price is from the shop's own ordering page, which lists no slice price.