Plain

Why people love it

Yelpers repeatedly call it the best cheesecake they have had: light, creamy yet firm, not too sweet. One found it overrated with a weird base.

What people mention most

• best ever3
• amazing2
• solid1
• single serving1
• favorite1
• took some home1
• plain1
• went back for more1

Criticism

• overrated1
• weird base1

On the menu

Palm-sized individual plain cheesecake tart from the Nolita shop open since 1975: airy, mild and custardy on a loose graham crust, with 20-plus flavors alongside.