Sarge's Homemade Cheesecake - Original New York

Why people love it

Praised as huge, creamy and better than Junior's; two diners found it dry and crumbly, including one strawberry slice that fell apart.

What people mention most

• huge2
• smooth2
• amazing1
• beats juniors1
• creamy1
• not too sweet1
• very dense1
• salty1

Criticism

• dry2
• crumbly2
• bland1

On the menu

Huge homemade Original New York cheesecake slice at the Murray Hill Jewish deli: very dense, slightly salty and crumbly, more sour than sweet.