Old Fashioned Chicken Soup with Matzo Ball at Sarge's Delicatessen & Diner

Matzo Ball Soup

Old Fashioned Chicken Soup with Matzo Ball

Sarge's Delicatessen & Diner · Murray Hill, Manhattan · $10.25

7.7 Forkelo score Medium confidence

Why people love it

A softball-sized matzo ball comes in a lighter-seasoned, homestyle broth with noodles. Portions are huge, and some diners find the soup a bit undersalted while others call it the best they have had.

What people mention most

  • best ever1
  • yelp september 20261
  • comforting meal1
  • named among dishes1
  • yelp march 20261
  • flavorful consomme1
  • yelp august 20251
  • softball-sized ball1

On the menu

Official February 2026 dine-in menu PDF, checked 2026-11-17, lists Old Fashioned Chicken Soup with matzo ball, kreplach, rice, or noodles at $10.25 at 548 3rd Ave. This card is the matzo-ball option. A Souper Soup at $15.40 and a 64-ounce take-out soup for two are different SKUs.

Similar matzo ball soups nearby

Also worth ordering at Sarge's Delicatessen & Diner