Deli
Sarge's Delicatessen & Diner
548 3rd Ave, New York, NY · Murray Hill, Manhattan
What to order.
-
Hot Pastrami Sandwich
Diners call it tender, flavorful and stacked high, Katz's quality without the line. Critics say fine-grained and mild; a few found it dry or bland.
8.5 Medium confidence -
Sarge's Homemade Cheesecake - Original New York
Praised as huge, creamy and better than Junior's; two diners found it dry and crumbly, including one strawberry slice that fell apart.
8.5 Medium confidence -
Old Fashioned Chicken Soup with Matzo Ball
A softball-sized matzo ball comes in a lighter-seasoned, homestyle broth with noodles. Portions are huge, and some diners find the soup a bit undersalted while others call it the best they have had.
7.7 Medium confidence -
Corned Beef or Pastrami Rueben
Open-faced corned beef or pastrami Reuben with Swiss and sauerkraut, grilled on rye. Diners praise tender piled meat, though one visit called the Reuben the only bright spot in a middling meal.
7.1 Medium confidence