forkelo✦
Get early access
14 inch pie with full pepperoni at John's of Bleecker Street

Pepperoni Pizza

14 inch pie with full pepperoni

John's of Bleecker Street · West Village, Manhattan · $28.50

9.2 Forkelo score Limited data
Directions Website

Why people love it

West Village brick oven pie, whole pies only, with pepperoni diners call the best they have had. Reviews are nearly all five stars; the lowest ones complain about service, not pepperoni.

What people mention most

  • classic2
  • worth the trip1
  • crispy crust1
  • cheese pull1
  • not too salty1
  • good sauce1
  • classic new york style1
  • subtle spice1

On the menu

Brick oven pie with tomato sauce and mozzarella topped with pepperoni, sold as a whole pie only.

Similar pepperoni pizzas nearby

#2 Old School Round with pepperoni (13 inch)Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria · New York 8.6 Limited data
$25.95 #3 Rustic Double PepperoniLombardi's · New York 8.4 Limited data
$28.00 #4 Pepperoni PieCello's Pizzeria · New York 8.0 Limited data
$35.00 #5 Pepperoni PieJonny's Pizza · New York 7.4 Limited data
$36.00 #6 Pepperoni (Medium 8x10)Ace's Pizza · New York 7.3 Limited data
$22.00