Forkelo ranking · Updated October 2026
6 pepperoni pizzas across New York City, ranked on what people say about the dish itself — never the restaurant's overall rating.
John's of Bleecker Street · West Village, Manhattan
12 dish-specific mentions · 100% positive · 1 source type · menu verified October 2026
West Village brick oven pie, whole pies only, with pepperoni diners call the best they have had. Reviews are nearly all five stars; the lowest ones complain about service, not pepperoni.
Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria · Midtown, Manhattan
9 dish-specific mentions · 89% positive · 1 source type · menu verified October 2026
Midtown coal oven round pie with thin crispy crust and flavorful sauce, topped with pepperoni. Diners call it excellent; one notes the 13 inch pie cuts into small pieces.
Lombardi's · Nolita, Manhattan
11 dish-specific mentions · 73% positive · 1 source type · menu verified October 2026
Famous coal oven pie topped with double pepperoni that curls into crispy cups. Diners rate it great with good sauce; two older reviews say the pepperoni was skimpy.
Cello's Pizzeria · East Village, Manhattan
12 dish-specific mentions · 75% positive · 1 source type · menu verified October 2026
East Village thin crust pie with small, crunchy, well browned pepperoni and a charred edge. Many praise the umami pepperoni; a few call it just alright and some report slow delivery.
Jonny's Pizza · Lower East Side, Manhattan
12 dish-specific mentions · 67% positive · 1 source type · menu verified October 2026
Lower East Side thin crust pie with plenty of crispy pepperoni, often with vodka sauce or hot honey. Fans love it; some report sparse pepperoni, dry crust or a missing cheese layer.
Ace's Pizza · Williamsburg, Brooklyn
11 dish-specific mentions · 73% positive · 1 source type · menu verified October 2026
Detroit style pan pie with small pepperoni that crisps into cups and cheesy caramelized edges. Fans call the pepperoni a standout; one finds it oily and salty and a few found the hype too big.
Every score is built from evidence about the specific dish: how often locals recommend it, how strongly, how recently, and whether independent sources agree. A restaurant's overall star rating is never converted into a dish score.
Quality and confidence are reported separately. A dish two people loved can score high, but it is marked limited data until more evidence backs it up. The whole calculation — every constant, and three dishes worked through line by line — is written out on the methodology page.
Think we got it wrong? Tell us what’s better.
