Forkelo ranking · Updated October 2026
9 ice cream across New York City, ranked on what people say about the dish itself — never the restaurant's overall rating.
Eddie's Sweet Shop · Forest Hills, Queens
13 dish-specific mentions · 85% positive · 1 source type · menu verified October 2026
Rich house-made ice cream under real whipped cream in a time-capsule parlor. Fans call it the best sundae around; critics find it no better than a chain scoop and pricey for cash only.
Sugar Hill Creamery · Harlem, Manhattan
4 dish-specific mentions · 75% positive · 1 source type · menu verified October 2026
Handmade scoop with cheesecake crunch and fruit that regulars call a lifelong favorite. Critics find some flavors at the shop taste like grocery-store ice cream.
Malai · Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn
7 dish-specific mentions · 71% positive · 1 source type · menu verified October 2026
Subtle, not-too-sweet rose with crunchy cinnamon almonds. Fans call it the signature; critics find the shop's flavors too subtle for the price.
Max & Mina's · Flushing, Queens
5 dish-specific mentions · 60% positive · 1 source type · menu verified October 2026
Playful cake batter scoop loaded with sprinkles and cookies that fans single out. Critics find the mix-ins soggy and the small cups pricey.
Caffè Panna · Gramercy, Manhattan
9 dish-specific mentions · 67% positive · 1 source type · menu verified October 2026
Thick, creamy vanilla with free panna cream and hot fudge that fans call the best in the city. Critics find it overhyped, sweet and small for the line.
Morgenstern's Finest Ice Cream · Lower East Side, Manhattan
5 dish-specific mentions · 60% positive · 1 source type · menu verified October 2026
Strong, sweet milk tea flavor that fans say tastes just like the Hong Kong drink. Critics find it closer to caramel with the tea faint, and the shop overall too sweet.
Brooklyn Ice Cream Factory · DUMBO, Brooklyn
6 dish-specific mentions · 50% positive · 1 source type · menu verified October 2026
Rich, nutty butter pecan that visitors call amazing, and it sells out. Critics find the scoops small and pricey for basic flavors.
Chinatown Ice Cream Factory · Chinatown, Manhattan
5 dish-specific mentions · 60% positive · 1 source type · menu verified October 2026
Smooth, fragrant scoop with bits of real lychee that fans call perfection. Critics found it rock hard and the scoops pricey for the size.
Julia Jean's · Lower East Side, Manhattan
3 dish-specific mentions · 67% positive · 1 source type · menu verified October 2026
Deeply salty, sweet and creamy caramel that one fan calls the best they have had. A critic found it sour and too sweet.
Every score is built from evidence about the specific dish: how often locals recommend it, how strongly, how recently, and whether independent sources agree. A restaurant's overall star rating is never converted into a dish score.
Quality and confidence are reported separately. A dish two people loved can score high, but it is marked limited data until more evidence backs it up. The whole calculation — every constant, and three dishes worked through line by line — is written out on the methodology page.
Think we got it wrong? Tell us what’s better.
