forkelo✦
Get early access
Blueberry Cheesecake at Sugar Hill Creamery

Ice Cream

Blueberry Cheesecake

Sugar Hill Creamery · Harlem, Manhattan · $7.75

7.4 Forkelo score Limited data
Directions Website

Why people love it

Handmade scoop with cheesecake crunch and fruit that regulars call a lifelong favorite. Critics find some flavors at the shop taste like grocery-store ice cream.

What people mention most

  • handmade1
  • crunch1
  • fruit1
  • made in house1

Criticism

  • guar gum1

On the menu

Handmade blueberry cheesecake ice cream with cheesecake pieces and blueberry swirl, scooped at the family-owned Harlem creamery.

Similar ice cream nearby

#1 Two-Scoop Sundae (house-made ice cream)Eddie's Sweet Shop · New York 8.7 Limited data
$12.00 #3 Rose with Cinnamon Roasted Almonds (pint price)Malai · New York 7.3 Limited data
$12.95 #4 SpongeBobMax & Mina's · New York 6.9 Limited data
$4.95 #5 Vanilla Scoop with PannaCaffè Panna · New York 6.7 Limited data
$7.00 #6 Hong Kong Milk Tea (pint price)Morgenstern's Finest Ice Cream · New York 6.6 Limited data
$14.00