forkelo✦
Get early access
Large Black & White Cookie at Orwashers

Black and White Cookie

Large Black & White Cookie

Orwashers · Upper East Side, Manhattan · $5.40

7.2 Forkelo score Limited data
Directions Website

Why people love it

A thick, cakey Upper East Side black and white that several call the best in the city. A few found it small or ordinary.

What people mention most

  • best ever2
  • cakey1
  • best in city1
  • mini cookies1

On the menu

Classic New York black and white cookie, thick and cakey; minis also sold.

Similar black and white cookies nearby

#1 Large Black and White CookieWilliam Greenberg Desserts · New York 8.4 Limited data
$4.50 #2 Black & White CookieZaro's Family Bakery - Grand Central · New York 8.0 Limited data
$4.99 #3 Black and White CookiesZabar's · New York 7.8 Limited data
$14.98 #4 Black and White CookieThe Pastry Box · New York 7.7 Limited data
$5.00 #6 Black & White CookieLassen & Hennigs · New York 6.3 Limited data
$3.95