forkelo✦
Get early access
Black and White Cookie at The Pastry Box

Black and White Cookie

Black and White Cookie

The Pastry Box · East Village, Manhattan · $5.00

7.7 Forkelo score Limited data
Directions Website

Why people love it

An East Village bakery whose buttery black and white cookie wins over skeptics with thick, distinct icings. Some still prefer its chocolate chip.

What people mention most

  • buttery1
  • thick frosting1
  • soft1
  • distinct icings1
  • best in city1

On the menu

Buttery black and white cookie with thick vanilla and chocolate frosting.

Similar black and white cookies nearby

#1 Large Black and White CookieWilliam Greenberg Desserts · New York 8.4 Limited data
$4.50 #2 Black & White CookieZaro's Family Bakery - Grand Central · New York 8.0 Limited data
$4.99 #3 Black and White CookiesZabar's · New York 7.8 Limited data
$14.98 #5 Large Black & White CookieOrwashers · New York 7.2 Limited data
$5.40 #6 Black & White CookieLassen & Hennigs · New York 6.3 Limited data
$3.95