Choco-Toffee Cookie

Why people love it

The choco-toffee cookie is thin and chewy, with toffee bits, a soft center, and a crunchy edge. Diners split between calling it one of the city's best and saying it did not live up to the wait.

What people mention most

• toffee in the dough1
• maldon salt1
• bittersweet chocolate1
• unanimous tasting winner1
• thin cookie1
• soft center1
• crunchy outside1
• melted in the mouth1

Criticism

• long wait1
• did not live up1
• too thin1
• not a thick cookie1

On the menu

Red Gate's labeled Choco-Toffee Cookie, a thin chocolate chip cookie with toffee in the dough, sold by the piece at 68 E 1st St. Not a black-and-white cookie.