Red Gate Bakery

What to order.

1. 🥇

   Choco-Toffee Cookie

   · See all chocolate chip cookies in New York City

   The choco-toffee cookie is thin and chewy, with toffee bits, a soft center, and a crunchy edge. Diners split between calling it one of the city's best and saying it did not live up to the wait.

   7.5 Medium confidence