Bagel
Bagel with Plain Cream Cheese
Shelsky's Brooklyn Bagels · Park Slope, Brooklyn · $6.99
5.8
Forkelo score
Medium confidence
Why people love it
Small, dense, carefully made bagels with standout seasoning that two critics rank near the top. Many diners call them tiny, pricey, stale late in the day, or over-baked.
What people mention most
- great texture2
- pricey2
- dense2
- small2
- well seasoned1
- creative spreads1
- best in area1
- sourdough starter1
Criticism
- tiny3
- pricey2
- mediocre2
- nothing special1
- stale late1