Shelsky's Brooklyn Bagels

What to order.

1. 🥇

   Bagel with Plain Cream Cheese

   $6.99 · See all bagels in New York City

   Small, dense, carefully made bagels with standout seasoning that two critics rank near the top. Many diners call them tiny, pricey, stale late in the day, or over-baked.

   5.8 Medium confidence