forkelo✦
Get early access

Pizza

NY Pizza Suprema

413 8th Ave, New York, NY · Midtown / Penn Station, Manhattan

Directions Website Call

What to order.

  1. NY Round Cheese Pizza (slice)

    $4.75 · See all new york-style pizzas in New York City

    Fans call the plain slice the best near Penn Station: crunchy crust, salty aged cheese, tangy sauce. Critics cite greasy, cold or soggy slices and tourist prices.

    8.2 Medium confidence