NY Round Cheese Pizza (slice) at NY Pizza Suprema

New York-Style Pizza

NY Round Cheese Pizza (slice)

NY Pizza Suprema · Midtown / Penn Station, Manhattan · $4.75

8.2 Forkelo score Medium confidence

Why people love it

Fans call the plain slice the best near Penn Station: crunchy crust, salty aged cheese, tangy sauce. Critics cite greasy, cold or soggy slices and tourist prices.

What people mention most

  • plain slice2
  • solid crust1
  • representative ny1
  • pricey1
  • crunchy crust1
  • salty cheese1
  • plain cheese best1
  • tomato sauce1

Criticism

  • greasy3
  • cold2
  • pricey2
  • lukewarm1
  • sour1

On the menu

The NY Round Cheese slice: thin, slightly charred crust with house tomato sauce, Pecorino Romano and Grande mozzarella.

Similar new york-style pizzas nearby