Paulie Gee's Slice Shop

What to order.

1. 🥇

   Cheese Slice

   $4.25 · See all new york-style pizzas in New York City

   Diners praise a thin, crispy cheese slice with char and a good cheese pull; Eater singles out its NY cheese slice. Critics say it is inconsistent, floppy or mediocre lately.

   7.9 Medium confidence