Cheese Slice

Why people love it

Diners praise a thin, crispy cheese slice with char and a good cheese pull; Eater singles out its NY cheese slice. Critics say it is inconsistent, floppy or mediocre lately.

What people mention most

• crispy3
• thin3
• pricey2
• cheese pull2
• huge1
• even bake1
• not sweet1
• classic ny slices1

Criticism

• dry1
• floppy1
• undercooked1
• small1
• mediocre1

On the menu

The plain round cheese slice at Paulie Gee's Greenpoint slice shop: thin, crisp, with a toasted undercarriage.