Original Slice

Why people love it

Critics and diners praise the house-milled crust, good sauce and old-school feel; Eater's critic ranks its cheese slice top three. Critics call it overhyped or burnt.

What people mention most

• not greasy2
• thin crust2
• classic2
• good sauce2
• flavorful crust1
• browned cheese1
• zesty sauce1
• nutty crust1

Criticism

• burnt2
• overhyped2
• overrated1
• overpriced1
• declining1

On the menu

The Original slice: a plain cheese slice on a thin crust made with house-milled flour.